Call (920) 731-2100

Our Team

The MIB Health Insurance experts have devoted over 35 years to helping clients find the customized Health Insurance they need. We know Health Insurance is confusing and complicated. Mike Dietz bought Midwest Insurance Brokerage in June of 2006 and brought his Employer Group Benefits business under the MIB name. He has engaged the changing insurance industry over the years and learned to navigate the overly complicated system to help his clients. In 2021, MIB made another name change to MIB Health Insurance to better represent our Employee Benefit, Medicare, and Individual and Family clients. MIB also started a member benefits program called MIB Plus providing innovative and personalized Health Insurance services to clients with all kinds of unique Health Insurance needs.

Many of our clients are referred to us through sub-agents who specialize in other lines of insurance or financial services. These professionals trust Midwest Health Insurance to find innovative Health Insurance plans to save their clients time and money that provides peace of mind.

We service our clients for life with a 99% client satisfaction rate. We built our business by one satisfied client sharing their MIB story with a friend or family member. Whether it is an enrollment, claim, or benefit issue, we put our customers first. We value our clients and the friends and family they trust us with.

Meet our team of Health Insurance experts

Our team wants to better understand your Health Insurance story so they can help you find the Health Insurance solutions you need. Everyone at MIB Health Insurance is here to give you peace of mind that you and your family or employees have the proper financial protection and benefits.

Known for his innovative solutions, Mike is well-respected throughout the insurance community. He has a “work hard, play hard” mentality and shares that with his employees.

Fun Facts:

• Mike started in the health insurance industry from his basement.

• He has completed 2 Ironman triathlons in Madison, WI.

• When not at the office, Mike likes to listen to live music with family & friends & sip on a cold beer or wine.

Mike Dietz

President

Lynn has been with MIB since 2006. She is the glue that holds the MIB office together and is willing to take on any task that is asked of her.

Fun Facts:

• Lynn has two daughters and one son-in-law and loves spending time with them.

• When not in the office, Lynn enjoys spending time at her cottage with family.

• Lynn's family lives in Clintonville - she prefers the country lifestyle.

Lynn Weatherwax

Office Manager

Mackenzie joined MIB in June of 2018. She works with individuals and businesses in Medicare, Marketplace coverage, and Employee Benefits, helping clients navigate complex insurance options and find coverage that best fits their needs.

Fun Facts:

• Mackenzie is Mike Dietz’s oldest (and favorite) of two daughters.

• Outside of work, she enjoys spending time with her one-year-old daughter, who keeps life busy and fun.

• She loves to travel—her favorite place is a tropical beach with a margarita in hand.

Mackenzie Hopfensperger

Agent

Cameron started with MIB in February of 2020 to support the sales team. He primarily works in the Employee Benefits business, focusing on customer service and support.

Fun Facts:

• Born & raised in Appleton, Wisconsin, he was excited to start his career in his hometown.

• Cameron graduated from UW-Whitewater in December 2019 with a BS in Marketing and Management.

• In his free time, Cameron and his wife enjoy spending time outside with their dogs and playing pickleball!

Cameron Rohde

Agent

Marcia has been with MIB for over 20 years. She manages MIB’s Medicare market and is the office expert when it comes to anything Medicare

Fun Facts:

• When not in the office, Marcia can be found on the lake at the family cottage in Shawano.

• Marcia is known for going above and beyond with her clients and lending a helping hand to them in any way she can.

• As a member of St. Pius X in Appleton, Marcia volunteers her time and talents at her parish!

Marcia Dietz

Agent

Michelle has been with MIB for over 20 years. She originally managed MIB’s Individual ACA Marketplace clients but has expanded into the Medicare business by transitioning her current clients into Medicare!

Fun Facts:

• Michelle, her husband, and son live on a dairy farm where they have a growing number of cows.

• She loves cheering on Wisconsin sports teams - Go Pack Go! And she also loves cheering on her son’s basketball and baseball teams.

Michelle Niemuth

Agent

Jeff started with MIB in January of 2020 to help grow Direct Access Navigator, which is now rebranded as MIB Plus with many additional services for member clients.

Fun Facts:

• Having worked in the Insurance industry for over 24 years, Jeff is excited to advocate for consumers to make sure they are not taken advantage of by the Healthcare System.

• Jeff loves spicy foods and puts habanero peppers on his corn flakes!

• When not at the office, Jeff likes to hoist a Jameson at the bar with his family and friends. Cheers!

Jeff Flannigain

Agent

Nash joined the MIB Team in 2024, transitioning into the Health Insurance Industry with a focus on guiding clients of all ages toward solutions that best fits their needs and budget

Fun Facts:

• Nash can often be found in the “Great Outdoors” spending free time with family and friends hunting, fishing, or golfing.

• He makes homemade sausages and takes backyard grilling very seriously.

• Nash has always been the go-to guy—whether it’s college homework, tackling home renovations, or finding you the right health insurance plan!

Nash Herbst

Agent

The Company We Keep

Office Hours

Monday - Friday  8:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Summer Hours:
Monday - Thursday  8:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Friday  8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

 

Connect With Us

©2025 MIB Health Insurance